This is the beginning of two men’s journey to find the best burger in St. Louis. For the next few month, Noah and I will be traveling around the city tasting different burger from restaurants, pubs, fast-food chains…you name it, we’ll probably try it. Last Friday we took the inaugural visit to the “Fatted Calf” in Clayton.
Here are our thoughts:
Atmosphere: (Noah)The atmosphere was weird. I felt like I had been transported back in time 500 years into an old English tavern, and then that tavern was transported 500 years forward in time and placed in the middle of a metropolis. It was kinda fun to be in such a funky room, but still be able to see the buildings of Clayton. However, it was really dark inside, which was kind of annoying. That, combined with small tables, and I give The Fatted Calf a 6/10 atmosphere.
(Charles): It is dark and tavern-like inside the restaurant with exposed wooden beams and medieval banners on the walls. I actually looked for mead on the menu. The two person tables were a bit small but we didn’t want to be those people that grab a larger table just for the two of us. Also…the chairs were uncomfortable. Whatever the decor they were aiming for, they got it. The creativity is certainly original and well-done. (5)
Service: (Noah) The servers at the ordering counter were helpful, especially to someone who had never been to their restaurant before. However, it’s kind of a weird system of ordering that I didn’t really like. Almost like a mix between fast food and a sit down restaurant. It wasn’t terrible but I give The Fatted Calf a 7/10 for Service.
(Charles) Everyone was nice and answered questions with humor. They were quick, efficient and kind. (8)
Taste: (Noah) To say the burger was underwhelming would be an understatement. Probably the best part of the whole thing was the bun. I ordered a burger with cheddar, lettuce, and bacon. However, when they brought the burger to me, you would have thought I had ordered a salad. The lettuce leaf they gave me almost covered the whole paper boat the burger was in! The bacon was alright, but instead of a slice of cheddar, or some shredded cheddar cheese, they put some weird cheddar “spread” on the burger. Needless to say, the spread was not very good at all. Also, I ordered my burger to be cooked medium, and it seemed a little too well done. The fries and onion rings were actually pretty good, and I would almost rather eat those than the burger.
(Charles) I really wanted to like the burger but I felt like I had to pull more off of it than eat it. There were a pile of onions and an entire lettuce leaf that dwarfed the bun. You never want to prune your burger. I’m not as much a fan of the cheddar cheese spread as I know some are. Once I got it to a point where I could eat it, it was really pretty good. A little more done than I ordered, but good. (7)
Menu Variety: (Noah) Menu variety revolves around burger toppings. They have quite a large selection to choose from, but it hardly comes close Five Guys for example. 8/10.
(Charles) They have a lot of toppings available, and a number of other sandwiches you could order. If you’re creative, which I am NOT, this is a great place to try a lot of different things you make up. As well, there are salads, onion rings, fries, etc. They even have this green stuff that they informed me was salad dressing. I’m not so sure. (8)
Presentation: (Noah) Presentation here is nothing special. The burger came in a large paper boat, and the fries came in a smaller one. No added frills or anything. 6/10.
(Charles) Everything is served in paper boats. Simple and effective with no frills. (5)
Value: (Noah)The food is REALLY overpriced. I understand that they need to make money to stay open, but maybe if they lowered they would get more customers. 2/10
(Charles) This was the worst. Everything is over-priced given what you get. It’s obviously meant to appeal to the higher-end Clayton lunch crowd, but it was just too much. (3)
Summary: (Noah) Like I mentioned earlier, it was really fun to be in such a cool atmosphere in Clayton. The crowd around us was very lively, which added to the fun. This may seem kinda funny, but when it came time to leave, we had no idea what to do with our trash. Nitpicky detail but still worth a mention. Well, as an overall burger experience, I give The Fatted Calf a solid 5/10. It is quite clearly not the best burger in St. Louis.
(Charles) I think Noah and I enjoyed our visit to the Fatted Calf. We had a good conversation and the atmosphere continued to pick up the longer we stayed there. Nearby parking is expensive…which I hate. They have hat and coat racks all over the place…which I love. I think we ordered a decent, over-priced burger, their service was quick and friendly, and I experienced a high level of lethargy upon leaving (important in eating any burger for lunch). Overall (5).





